Whines the child. Twenty years later, that same kid can't quite figure out why he keeps getting ripped off in his purchases - why products that say all the right things on the box, and have the right price, keep disappointing him.
So I noticed my wife had bought a gardening tool, primarily because of its shape. It is Fiber Reinforced Plastic, but it's a digging tool so parts of it will see high stresses. In the past, it would have been made from steel, because regular nylon (or gods forbid, PVC), while light weight, would have cracked and split.
FRP to the rescue, because it says right here on the package that FRP is "stronger than steel"! Wowser!
Well, yes, but also no.
FRP is stronger than steel by weight, but they never actually use a weight and thickness of the FRP that would be sufficient to match steel. In order for an FRP item to be "stronger than steel", you would have to use so much mass and thickness that the tool would become completely impractical to use or manufacture: it would be much bulkier than making it from almost any metal other than lead or mercury. ;)
So an FRP tool, made the same way as a steel tool, will never come close to having the same strength as steel. OTOH, not everyone can handle the weight of a highly durable tool. Once you get old, you start thinking about fatigue, arthritis, tendonitis, etc and you may be quite willing to trade some durability for reduced fatigue. The FRP tool in this case will weigh much less than the equivalent functionality rendered in steel.
Even so, I'm gonna start collecting the parts to make one from steel now, so when the FRP one breaks, I can hand her a gift and a fait accompli. :)
This is simple arithmetic, but: an inability to do simple elementary school arithmetic (and perhaps a small amount of solid geometry in this case - also elementary school stuff) is costing a lot of good folks out there to send good money after bad.
Speaking of buying choices and math, marketroids are still being allowed to lie to you about "peak HP". I'm pretty sure I already posted a rant about that non-existent attribute long ago, but if not, I will write one, because it's been chapping my ass for forty years or so. EDIT: apparently I did not write one, so I shall do one soon or even next.
~≈{👁}≈~














